When autumn winds churn Cape Cod Bay each November, that seemingly placid sea broils in angry froth and surrenders cherished secrets along its high tide wrackline. This year has been no exception, and in fact has offered more than its annual share of ocean treasures. From a large blue shark to electric torpedo rays, interesting critters have dotted bayside beaches from Provincetown to Bourne.  Large ocean sunfish (Mola mola) joined the castaways as reported in Turtle Journal on November 1st [Exotic Ocean Sunfish (Mola mola)] and November 12th [Two Giant Ocean Sunfish Wash Up on Cape Cod Beaches].  The team confirmed the stranding of yet another sunfish on Thursday at Boathouse Beach on South Wellfleet’s Lieutenant Island.
Ocean Sunfish on Boathouse Beach, Lieutenant Island
Lieutenant Island’s north facing beach takes a beating each fall and winter as prevailing north and northwest winds pound the shoreline. So, any research visit to Wellfleet includes a quick survey of this area. As we crossed the footpath by the boathouse, a good-sized ocean sunfish occupied the spot where family bathers congregate each summer. The rising tide lapped a few feet below the carcass, preparing to reclaim this secret on the next cycle. We plan a revisit on Friday’s low tide to attempt a necropsy to determine … if we can … the cause of death of this fourth large ocean sunfish we have encountered in November. Hopefully, the sea will cooperate.
We took some general, preliminary measurements in case the bay decides to permanently retrieve its treasure. We made the mistake of not doing so at the Shirttail Point ocean sunfish early this month because its necropsy had been scheduled for the next day. Spring tides reclaimed that animal before the scientific team could reach it. We won’t make that mistake a second time.
Skin Discoloration Suggests Older Carcass
This Lieutenant Island ocean sunfish measured 6 feet 1.5 inches from the tip of its snout to the trailing edge of its caudil fin. It measured 7 feet 4 inches from the bottom of its anal fin to the top of its dorsal fin. As you can see from the photograph above, its skin shows discoloration and cellular breakdown hinting that the carcass has been bouncing around the bay for some time. We’ll know with more certainty after Friday’s necropsy.
The wind backed to the west for Thursday night’s sea turtle patrols, still whistling in at over 15 knots. A few sea turtles had come in during the day scattered from one surprising ridley at Ballston Beach in Truro on the ocean side to another Kemp’s ridley at Linnell Landing in Brewster. A green sea turtle also appeared, unusually encrusted with barnacles and algae; the greens we find each fall are normally pristinely clean as though they had just emerged from a car wash. While the Turtle Journal team found no sea turtles on our legs of the patrol from Great Island in Wellfleet to Ryder Beach in Truro, the stunning, unspoiled beauty of a Cape Cod sunset unlittered by sights of human civilization creates a balanced serenity in an otherwise unruly, frayed and jaded world.
Turtle Journal learned today of the sixth and seventh torpedo ray sightings of the fall season. You may recall that we had reported previously about Shocking Discovery! Torpedo Ray in Wellfleet Bay, Torpedoes Los!, and More Torpedo Rays Raise More Questions. Today’s reports add to the mystery of torpedo ray strandings on bayside beaches this season. The “old boys network” says that a couple or three torpedo rays a season may have been the most documented by observant naturalists in other years, and many seasons saw no torpedo rays at all. There’s always the possibility that greater awareness of this cool critter has prompted more consolidated reporting. Whatever the cause, Turtle Journal hopes to document this season so that successor naturalists will have a base line against which to judge their findings.
Bob Prescott, Don Lewis & Kemp’s Ridley at Tip of Great Island (1999)
The National Park Service plays a key role in our sea turtle rescue operations each fall season. The long, long stretch of bayside beach from Pamet River to the tip of Great Island proves very difficult to patrol by foot at every high tide. Miles and miles of sandy beach with no public roadways to leapfrog out to the distant tip of Jeremy Point. Several Novembers ago, Bob Prescott (Wellfleet Sanctuary director) and I returned from a long, cold Brewster beach patrol at 10:30 pm to find a blinking light on the Sanctuary turtle line. “We just got back from a beach walk out to Jeremy Point,” an anonymous voice relayed, “where we found a stranded sea turtle. We didn’t disturb it. Left it on the beach. It was alive when we left.” Just what we wanted to hear so late at night with freezing rain, howling winds and plunging temperatures. We sped to the parking lot on Griffin Island and hiked the three miles out (wind at our backs) and three miles back (sleet in our faces) with a small Kemp’s ridley tucked under my overcoat.
Torpedo Ray Found North of Great Island by NPS
Now NPS rangers graciously patrol the bayside beaches all the way down Great Island in search of cold-stunned sea turtles. When they find stranded turtles, the rangers deliver them to Mass Audubon’s Wellfleet Bay Wildlife Sanctuary for triage and stabilization before the turtles are driven by volunteers to the New England Aquarium for medical care and rehabilitation. But it all starts with the turtle “EMTs” who rescue them off the beaches and thanks to the National Park Service the long, lonely stretch from Griffin Island to Jeremy Point is no longer a “sea turtle dead zone” during stranding season.
Torpedo Ray with Superimposed 2-Foot Measuring Stick
Today, Ranger Kelly patrolled that lonesome stretch and discoverd a freshly beached torpedo ray south of Bound Brook (yes, the Bound Brook of American toad fame) in north Wellfleet. He called the 24/7 Turtle Journal hotline (508-274-5108) to alert us to the discovery, and our team will dispatch to the site tomorrow to obtain scientific measurements. For general reference, we’ve inserted a 24-inch bar into the photograph above to hint at the large size of this electric ray. We thank Ranger Kelly and the NPS for the three photographs of the torpedo ray for tonight’s post.
Â
Senior Mass Audubon Naturalist Dennis Murley
Dennis Murley of Mass Audubon’s Wellfleet Bay Wildlife Sanctuary coordinates beach searches for cold-stunned sea turtles during the fall.  We called him after our talk with Ranger Kelly to alert him that his patrols might encounter the torpedo ray and that we would be returning to the animal on Wednesday to take measurements and to investigate possible causes of its demise. Dennis told us that he had rescued a trapped torpedo ray in North Truro last week. A lifelong Cape Codder, Dennis exclaimed, “The biggest darn torpedo ray I’ve ever seen.” He said the ray had been trapped by a falling tide and Dennis was able to drag it to open water where he saw it swim away. Because of the location and the timing, there is a possibility that the ranger’s find (torpedo ray #6) and the ray that Dennis rescued (torpedy ray #7) are one and the same. We’ll know more after we examine it on Wednesday.
(ASIDE: Are we the only ones who are left wondering about Dennis, who is widely known for walking barefoot year around, and his encounter with the live, 220-volt electrically charged torpedo ray? That’s what we call a natural, non-habit forming stimulant!)
The weather turned cold today with brisk north-northwesterly winds shuttling heavy autumn clouds over the Cape, ladened with promise of brief winter days and long winter nights. Birds hunkered in leeward coves to wait out the blow. Those winds abetted astronomically high tides to drive two large ocean sunfish onto north-facing Cape Cod beaches. Each measured nearly seven feet in diameter and washed ashore on either side of the Cape Cod Canal: one in Brewster and the other in Bourne.
Students from Ipswich Examine Linnell Landing Ocean Sunfish
We received the first call around noon through the National Marine Life Center in Buzzards Bay when a family spotted a huge, unidentified fish on the Sagamore Beach shore. Once direct communication was established, the family sent cell phone pictures that confirmed the animal’s identify as a large ocean sunfish. When we called Krill Carson from the NEBShark Project to report this finding, she told us that she was en route to a reported ocean sunfish stranding at Linnell Landing in Brewster. Since she was in Middleboro on the mainland side of the canal and we were in Eastham on the Outer Cape, we switched critters. Krill would check out the Sagamore sunfish and we would examine the Brewster creature. Light would be fading fast on a mid-November afternoon, and each sunfish needed to be documented before sunset … and before another astronomically high tide might drag it back out to sea.
Large Ocean Sunfish Deposited with Astronomically High Tide
We parked at the Brewster Historical Society and hiked the back trail to the beach. Directly in front of the beach stairs we found a very large ocean sunfish that had been deposited on the tide. A group of four boys from the North Shore joined us to learn more about this strange discovery on a bayside beach.Â
Large Ocean Sunfish with Its Truncated Caudal (Tail) Fin
The sunfish measured six feet eight inches (curved surface) from tip of snout to trailing edge of caudal fin. It measured seven feet five inches from the tip of the dorsal (top) fin to the tip of the anal (bottom) fin. The dorsal fin was two feet four and a half inches high, and the anal fin was two feet three and a half inches low.
Leaving Brewster and the Linnell Landing sunfish, we drove down the main Cape highway, Route 6. The sun had long set when we reached the Sagamore Bridge and zigzagged through unlit backstreets to Phillips Road along Cape Cod Bay. We crossed the coastal dune and saw a large shadowy shape illuminated by the dim ocean glow.
Ocean Sunfish on Dark Sagamore Beach
Krill had already inspected this animal and had taken a small tissue sample for analysis. Just to be sure, though, we took measurements for our own records and for comparision with the Linnell Landing sunfish.
Sue Wieber Nourse Records Ocean Sunfish Measurements
The fun part is trying to take measurements and photographs in the pitch black night. Luckily, our camera comes with infrared focus … and the hand-held cellphone offers illumination to read tapes and lighted keyboards to enter the data. The Sagamore Beach sunfish measured six feet eight inches (curved surface) from tip of snout to trailing edge of caudal fin. The doral fin had been sliced and its top was missing, so our tip of dorsal to tip of anal fin measurement is a bit short at six feet ten inches. The animal’s girth (curved measurment) reached four feet seven inches.
The torpedo mystery continues and deepens. You may have already read in Turtle Journal about the first three torpedo rays that washed up on Cape Cod beaches. (See Shocking Discovery! Torpedo Ray in Wellfleet Bay and Torpedoes Los!). Since our last posting, two more torpedo ray deaths have been confirmed: one in Brewster and another in Sandwich. Both were females, bringing the total to five dead torpedo rays; four confirmed as female, one not examined by the Turtle Journal team.
Cellphone Picture of Female Torpedo Ray in Brewster
On Sunday evening, we received correspondence from Jackie, a Turtle Journal reader from Chatham on the elbow of Cape Cod. She had encountered an unidentified creature, presumably a skate, on the beach between Ellis and Linnell Landings in Brewster on October 31st. Jackie estimated the length and the width of the animal to be around three feet. Realizing that what she found was not a skate, she searched the web to find our postings of the torpedo ray. While Jackie apologizes for the photo quality (since it came from her cellphone), her images provide excellent documentation of the torpedo ray and its gender identification. Thank you, Jackie!
Fifth Torpedo Ray to Wash Up on Cape Cod Beaches
Mystery torpedo ray number five drifted ashore in Sandwich. At noon yesterday (Monday), Vinny from Sandwich … the resident who reported the third torpedo ray last week … called the Turtle Journal 24/7 hotline (508-274-5108). He found another ray on Carlton Shoals in Sandwich, just a little further to the east than his first discovery. Luckily, Sue Wieber Nourse was exploring Sandy Neck in neighboring Barnstable and responded to the site to examine the specimen.Â
Seagull Munches on Torpedo Ray at Carlton Shores, Sandwich
By the time she arrived, local gulls were licking their chops in delight after munching another tasty seafood morsel. They had already stipped clean the caudal fin, making length measurements a bit iffy at approximately 3.5 feet. The width of this torpedo ray across the pectoral fin was two feet three inches. (You may recall that the other Sandwich torpedo ray measured two feet five inches across its pecs.) Without Don’s back for a more precise (sic) measurement of the critter’s weight, Sue estimated the weight at around 40 pounds.
Questions still loom about why we are seeing these offshore rays washing up on our inner Cape Cod beaches this fall. So far, Turtle Journal has no answers to share.
Three Bay Scallops Washed Up on Indian Neck, Wellfleet
As the Turtle Journal team combed the tidal flats of Indian Neck just south of the boat entrance to Wellfleet Harbor, we discovered a large number of bay scallops that had been deposited in the shallows by a previous high tide.  They appeared around, maybe just below, legal harvesting size, and had somehow been dislocated from their deeper locations in Wellfleet Bay between Indian Neck to the east and Great Island to the west. Seagulls were having a feast, prying open the shells and stripping out the meat. [ASIDE: You may have gotten the impression from this and previous posts that seagulls on the Outer Cape enjoy a fairly easy life and a luxuriant palate. They don’t seem to be bothered by the moral dilemma of shellfish sizing rules.]Â
Bay Scallop Opens and Snaps Shut Again
Bay scallops (Pecten irradians) should not be confused with much larger deep sea scallops (Placopecten megallancius) that are harvested off the coast in areas such as Georges Bank. Bay scallops are sweeter, more tender and much more flavorful. They are also rare and very difficult to obtain, having been harvested to near exhaustion in pressured coastal habitats. Today, sea scallops account for the overwhelming bulk of the commercial scallop fisheries and are likely to be the menu item sitting on your plate. If and when you can order bay scallops, do so. You will savor the difference.
The shell-clapping behavior illustrated in the video is used by bay scallops to drive jets of water for propulsion to evade predators and to move toward sources of food. Movement is created by contraction of the yummy adductor muscle.  The process doesn’t quite work as well when being held in mid-air by a human hand, but it gives us an opportunity to examine this artistically exquisite culinary delight.
Two Hinged Shells Held Together by Edible Adductor Muscle
Scallops consist of two hinged shells (hence: bivalve) connected together by an adductor muscle. This thick white fleshy muscle, the adductor, is the “scallop” that we actually eat; all the rest of the animal is scraped out and tossed back out to sea to re-enter the food chain. (The entire scallop is actually edible, but U.S. preference is to eat only the adductor muscle.)
Â
Colorful Multihued Shells & Beautiful Blue Eyes
Bay scallop habitat is the subtidal zone in five to twenty-five feet of water. Scallops spend the first week or so of life as free-floating plankton. After seven to ten days a juvenile scallop develops byssal threads projecting from its foot and attaches itself to a substrate. The preferred substrate is eelgrass (Zoestera marina) where juvenile scallops are protected from voracious predators. They can detach themselves at any time, and after a year or so, the mature scallop breaks free of the eelgrass and settles on sandy and muddy bottoms of harbors and estuaries. This behavior is unlike their clam relatives such as quahogs and soft-shelled clams that prefer to burrow into sandy, silty bottoms. Bay scallops reach reproductive maturity around 12 months and will spawn only once in its lifetime.
Coastal development adversely impacts scallop habitat primarily through silt runoff that smothers eelgrass beds. In estuaries that permit dense boat moorings, such as Sippican Harbor, the constant swinging of boats on mooring lines mows eelgrass beds, while added silting and shading thwart growth of new plants. Overfishing of bay scallops has been a big problem for sustainable populations, as has the decrease in water quality and clarity, and obviously the drastic reduction in viable eelgrass beds.
“Ol’ Blue Eyes” Himself Would Be Jealous
Scallops are unusual among shellfish in that they frequently rest with their shells open, creating a one-quater inch gap between shells. Nestled along the mantel are rows of brilliantly colored blue eyes and fleshy tentacles. Both eyes and tentacles funtion as sensory organs. Those beautiful blue eyes would have made Frank Sinatra jealous because each animal has 30 to 40 of them.  Scallop eyes are similar to human eyes in that each one contains a lens, a blue iris, a retina & a cornea, and each eye is attached to an optic nerve. Eyes are sensitive to movement and to shadows, enabling the scallop to detect and thereby to avoid predators.
Blue Eyes along Perimeter; Chemosensory Tentacles Below
Blue scallop eyes are scattered along the outer circumference. Inside the eyes the mantel is ringed by fleshy, chemosensory protuberances called tentacles that are sensitive to odors and to changes in water temperature.
Chemosensory Tentacles Above; Gills Below
Bay scallops, like other bivalves, are filter feeders and their primary prey are diatoms (phytoplankton). With its two shells partially open, a scallop can pass large volumes of diatoms across its gills (orange ring below chemosensory tentacles above). Rows of cilia sweep diatoms across the gill surface, where mucus traps and concentrates diatoms for the palps. Palps are fleshy tissue on the gills that move diatoms toward the stomach where they are consumed as nutrients and transported throughout the scallop via an open circulatory system.
Edible Adductor Muscle Holds Shells Together
The delicious adductor muscle makes humans the principal predators of bay scallops. In the plankton stage, scallops are easy prey for fish and other marine animals. As they grow scallops become prey for crabs and sea birds. Seastars and oyster drills prey on adult scallops, as do ubiquitous seagulls when they get a chance. Humans, though, create the greatest impact on scallop populations. Overfishing has driven bay scallops into extirpation in many estuaries. Habitat destruction and reduced water quality have exacerbated population declines.
Bay Scallop:Â A Gourmet Work of Art
Sue Wieber Nourse led a bay scallop research and restoration project in Sippican Harbor with her Tabor Academy advanced marine science students during the early 2000s. In collaboration with the Marion shellfish officer, Kevin Snow, Sue and her students spread seed scallops in protective cages in various substrates throughout the bottom of Sippican Harbor. Besides allowing students to engage in hands-on science with real world impact, Sue’s project increased bay scallop productivity in Sippican for several years. Unfortunately, the project was discontinued. You can read about this successful research and education program in a November 2001 article, “Tabor Students Keep Close Watch on Tiny Scallops,” in the New Bedford Standard Times.
Fun Facts: Life span – 20 to 26 months. Maximum size in Massachusetts – 3.5 inches. Reproductively mature in one year; spawns only once in a lifetime. Spawning time – June 15th to August 15th. Average number of eggs – 2 million. Shallow water habitat: prefer 5 to 25 feet depth. Minimum water coverage at low tide – 1 to 2 feet.
